Newark, Ohio’s Best Pizza Shops

Some of Newark, Ohio’s best pizza shops are not found online – yet. These shops are so well established that an added function like a website just fall short on their list of priorities. A typical night has people lined up outside of their doors, so who needs a website?

The Top Pizza Shops In Newark Ohio Are –

Don And Sue’s Pizza

Their mouth watering pizza is most notable by the type of pepperoni. They use the type that cups up into little grease cups. They have a thin crust. No delivery is available.

730 West Church Street
Newark, OH 43055-4230
(740) 522-8457

Website –

Plaza Pizza

Just great pizza. They’ve been in business for a very long time and they are a Newark, Ohio tradition. It’s not uncommon for visitors to return home with a few Plaza Pizzas in their car. No delivery is available and parking is a hassle. Warning – don’t go to the restaurant next door while waiting. They will run you out if you just order a drink while you wait on your Plaza Pizza to be made.

1130 Mount Vernon Road
Newark, OH 43055-3984
(740) 366-2511

Pizza Cottage

Until a few years ago, Pizza Cottage was only in Buckeye Lake. I was sad to see The Buxton leveled, but it was a relief to find out that it would be replaced by Pizza Cottage.

Pizza Cottage is more of a Chicago style pizza. It has a thicker crust and chunkier toppings. They only offer special deliveries to businesses and events.

If there are any that I forgot, let me know and tell me why you think they rate as a Newark favorite. There are many pizza shops, but very few reach the level of perfection that these have. Also, we have a list in the directory of Newark’s other pizza shops with websites.

Facebook comments:


Powered by Facebook Comments

5 visitors online now
3 guests, 2 bots, 0 members
Max visitors today: 7 at 01:56 am UTC
This month: 38 at 09-16-2017 05:07 pm UTC
This year: 38 at 09-16-2017 05:07 pm UTC
All time: 384 at 12-04-2012 09:04 am UTC